Account Based Pension vs Lump Sum: What’s the Difference?

When you retire and meet a condition of release, you can usually:

• Take your super as a lump sum
• Start an account based pension
• Use a combination of both

A lump sum removes money from the super system.
An account based pension keeps it in retirement phase where earnings are generally tax free.

The right choice depends on tax, flexibility, longevity risk and how you plan to use the money.

If you need a refresher on how an account based pension works, start here:
Account Based Pension

---

What happens when you take a lump sum?

A super lump sum means you withdraw money out of the super system.

Once withdrawn:

• It is no longer treated as super.
• Future investment earnings are taxed at your personal marginal rate.
• You have full control over how it is used.

From age 60, most lump sums from taxed super funds are tax free when withdrawn. Different rules apply for untaxed funds and for those under 60.

This option provides flexibility.

You might:

• Pay off a mortgage
• Renovate
• Invest outside super
• Hold cash

But the concessional super tax environment no longer applies once the money leaves.

---

What happens when you start an account based pension?

An account based pension keeps your money inside super in retirement phase.

• Investment earnings are generally tax free.
• Payments from taxed funds are generally tax free from age 60.
• A minimum withdrawal applies each year.

Your balance remains invested and fluctuates with markets.

It continues until the account runs out unless you commute it.

For minimum withdrawal mechanics, see:
Account Based Pension Minimum Drawdown Rates

---

Side by side comparison

Neither option guarantees income for life. That requires a different product structure.

---

Tax difference over time

Tax differences compound.

Imagine $800,000 invested earning 5 percent per year.

If held:

• Inside retirement phase pension: earnings are generally tax free.
• Outside super at a 30 percent marginal rate: earnings are taxed each year.

Over long periods, that difference can materially change outcomes.

Tax is not the only factor. But it matters.

---

Longevity and sequencing risk

Both options carry longevity risk.

Withdraw too much too early and capital falls.

There is also sequencing risk. Poor market returns early in retirement can permanently reduce sustainability if withdrawals continue.

A pension imposes a minimum withdrawal. A lump sum has no structure.

Some retirees value discipline. Others prefer flexibility.

Behaviour matters more than product choice.

---

Age Pension considerations

Both structures can affect Age Pension eligibility.

Impacts depend on:

• Where the money sits
• How it is invested
• Assets test values
• Deeming under the income test

For a detailed breakdown, see:
Account Based Pension Age Pension Impact

---

When might each make sense?

A lump sum may suit someone who:

• Needs a large one-off amount
• Has non-deductible debt to clear
• Wants full control outside super

An account based pension may suit someone who:

• Values tax efficiency
• Wants structured retirement income
• Intends to keep funds invested long term

Often the answer is not either or.

Many retirees:

• Take a lump sum for immediate needs
• Leave the balance in pension phase

The mix matters.

---

FAQs

Is it better to take a lump sum or an account based pension?

It depends on your circumstances. A lump sum offers flexibility and control, while an account based pension keeps money in the super system where earnings in retirement phase are generally tax free.

Are lump sums taxed differently to pensions?

Yes. Once money is withdrawn as a lump sum, it leaves the super system and future earnings are taxed at your personal marginal rate. Pension payments from taxed funds are generally tax free from age 60.

Can you take both a lump sum and a pension?

Yes. When you meet a condition of release, you can usually take a combination of lump sums and an income stream.

Does taking a lump sum affect the Age Pension?

Yes. Lump sums and pension balances can affect both the assets test and income test. The impact depends on how the money is structured and invested.

Does a lump sum avoid the transfer balance cap?

Yes. Lump sums do not count toward the transfer balance cap because the money leaves the retirement phase system.